
Today the Boy Scouts of America will be voting on a proposal to overturn the decades old policy that homosexuality goes against the core values of the BSA. As an Eagle Scout, I was never taught this as a value. We were taught to live our lives by the Scout Oath and Law. However, I was taught that living by Scout Oath and Law requires that we value the inherent worth and dignity of all those we meet and that our duty is to uphold “the rights of others” (Eagle Scout Charge). Many people have come up with their own interpretations of these promises, but what is written in my Boy Scout Handbook has not changed.
As Scouts, we attend interfaith services on Scouting weekends, camp with fellow Scouts, cheerfully serve our communities, and learn from the mentorship of strong adult volunteers. Sexual orientation does not affect any of Scouting’s activities. When we donned that uniform, we were equal, in the eyes of Man and God. We were simply Scouts. Our diversity as people unified us and enabled us to overcome any obstacles and challenges that we faced.
Kids that have gone through Scouting come out as participating citizens and civic leaders. The morals instilled in us compel us to speak out for what is just and to stand up for people when they are mistreated. We have been given some of the most amazing opportunities for personal, emotional and spiritual growth and development that any child could have.
Denying these chances to anyone is wrong. Telling a child that they are not worthy of these opportunities is wrong. Telling a child that their parents are not worthy is wrong. The BSA is still an incredible organization, but discrimination is tainting the BSA in the eyes of young American families and potential new Scouts, as well as those of us with Scouting’s highest honor.
Excluding any group of boys from Scouting not only deprives them of the Scouting’s benefits, but it also diminishes the experience of all scouts. Exclusion has no place in the oldest, largest and most effective youth development organization in our nation's history. Exclusion runs counter to those principles we as Scouts pledge. Scouting should be a home to every young man willing to serve his community, obey the Scout Law and who has the courage to stand up us a leader. Leadership requires bravery, which is one of the principles of the Scout Law. I trust that the leadership of the BSA can find the bravery to lead by choosing the inherent worth and dignity of every boy over a policy that goes against the very foundation of Scouting’s legacy.
Taking a step toward ending discrimination will not bring about the end of the BSA as some have suggested. In our collective history, the end of discriminatory practices has always had critics who suggested that ending the bigotry would bring about an end to our social mores. But history shows us consistently the reverse is always true. Embracing love and respect over hatred and exclusion always leads to a stronger society.
The BSA's own internal survey found that ending the ban on gay youth "would be consistent with the religious beliefs of the BSA's major chartered organizations." Not only is the BSA America's youth organization for leadership and character development, it is also one of the greatest interfaith organizations for America's youth. Even those that choose to label the BSA as a "Christian organization" are throwing away a major point of the last tenet of the Scout Law. For a Scout to be reverent he must respect the beliefs of others; this goes beyond respecting only that which he finds agreeable. Furthermore, with the majority of Americans and most Christian Americans supporting marriage equality, it is unfair to label Christianity or any religion as an excuse to continue discrimination in the BSA. As Christians, we are called “to love our neighbor as ourselves”. Love is not possible with hatred in our hearts and in our organizations.
The Boy Scouts certainly made me who I am today. Every boy should have the same opportunity. As Scouting’s Founder Baden-Powell said: “There is no teaching to compare with example.” I pray the BSA set the proper example with their vote.
Mark A. Yost, Jr., Esq.
Eagle Scout
Board Member, Equality Maryland

